Who Gets to Tell the Story?

By María Morena Vicente

In Animals, a kidnapping forces Mark Kimball, a candidate for mayor of Los Angeles, to confront a difficult question. When he receives a ransom demand for his son, he is prepared to pay whatever it takes to get him back. 

But when his son returns home safely, Mark discovers that the kidnappers have mistaken Héctor, the son of his undocumented employee, for his own child. Now he must decide whether Héctor's life is worth the same financial risk.

Ramón and his wife/ Netflix.

Mark eventually agrees to pay for the rescue, but the decision exposes a difference in how he approaches the lives of the two children. After Héctor is saved, Mark and Ramón agree to give the press a false account of what happened. Mark presents himself as the hero who risked everything to save a child, leaving out his initial reluctance to help, the money involved, and his own role in the violent plan. The story helps him win public support and, ultimately, the election.

Mark Kimball and Abigail, his wife / Netflix

The film raises questions that sit close to the Arithmetic of Compassion's work: whose suffering captures our attention, and what makes us willing to help? Mark's initial response to the kidnapping is shaped by his connection to the child he believes is his son. When the victim turns out to be Héctor, that connection is suddenly less direct, and the decision to help becomes more complicated. 

The public, meanwhile, hears a version of events that casts Mark as a hero while leaving Ramón's fear and his family's experience largely untold.

In the final press conference, the family shared their own version of events to help the campaign / Netflix.

The film invites us to consider how our sense of responsibility toward others can depend on who they are to us, and how the stories we hear can reinforce that selectivity. 

Would we respond differently if we knew the full story, or if the child in danger were someone else's from the start?